| Commentators as diverse as former President
Bill Clinton and Chester Finn, former assistant secretary of education in the Reagan
administration, have acknowledged Al Shanker's leading role as an advocate of
standards-based reform. The following are selections from his weekly "Where We
Stand" columns that explore various aspects of the issue. What Melony Learned
February 1997
Excerpts from an essay by an inner-city honor student paint a vivid picture of
the high cost of low standards.
Marking
Time
December 8, 1996
The national goals will never be achieved if we just continue to do what we have
always done.
A
Commonsense Approach
December 1, 1996
The TIMSS report calls into question a number of fashionable remedies for
mediocre student achievement.
National
(not Federal) Standards
April 28, 1996
Should children in Alabama learn a different kind of math from children in New
York?
What
Standards?
April 7, 1996
Students are unlikely to take learning seriously if we present them with English
courses based on standards like these.
Moving
Right Along
March 31, 1996
Higher standards are the foundation for improving the achievement of all our
students.
Passing
on Failure
March 24, 1996
"How is it that some students enter high school...without being able to read
or do simple math?" Social promotion is alive and well in schools across the
country.
Will CBEST Survive?
March 17, 1996
California's minimum competency test for new teachers has drawn fire. Opponents
argue that, since a disproportionate number of minorities have failed the test, students
of color are being deprived of the role models they need in school. Perhaps. But can we
really close the achievement gap by assigning students of color to teachers who don't meet
even a minimum standard?
Knowledge Still Counts
January 14, 1996
Does the information superhighway make the learning of knowledge obsolete? Not if
you want a better job with a higher salary.
An
'Average' Standard
October 29, 1995
For years, we've told ourselves that U.S. schools offer broad opportunity while
other systems focus only on the elite. Yet,consistent evidence from the AFT's
"Defining World Class Standards" series shows that students of average
ability in other industrialized nationsnot just university-bound achieversmeet much higher standards than the
average American student.
A
Baltimore Success Story
August 20, 1995
Faced with a struggling inner-city school full of poor, minority students, one Baltimore
principal decided that the curriculum of an elite private academy was just what was
needed. Within four years, the school's language arts and writing scores, which had been
consistently below the 30th percentile, soared to above the 60th percentile.
Work
in Progress
July 30, 1995
The AFT offers the first national survey of what states are doing about standards. The
good news is that 49 out of the 50 states are trying to revise their standards upward.
A
Reform that Works
July 16, 1995
A look at U.S. educational data shows that, when we expect more of students, they
rise to our standards.
Raising
the Ceilingand the Floor
June 4, 1995
The system we have now only challenges a small group of top students. Instead, one high
school principal gambled on the idea that raising the academic bar for all students would
raise their achievement. He was right.
Less
is More
May 28, 1995
American teachers are working longer and harder than teachers anywhere else in the
developed world. So why don't we outscore these nations in international comparisons?
It's not about how much time is spent in the classroom, but how that time is spent.
Raising
the Bar
May 14, 1995
Do tougher high school graduation requirements encourage learning or just discourage those
students who are already struggling? Data on graduation and drop-out rates indicate
that higher educational standards can help to raise the floor as well as the ceiling.
Too
Many Facts?
April 16, 1995
We should teach history by asking students to think about and use important facts they are
learning. In doing so, we eliminate the false dichotomy between the thoughts of E.D.
Hirsch and the teachings of John Dewey.
Feeding
and Weighing
April 9, 1995
Do externally administered exams distort instruction or help raise student
achievement? New research indicates that, without curriculum-based exams, our system does
not send signals that encourage effort and learning.
A
Citizen's Guide
March 12, 1995
Diane Ravitch puts the movement for standards squarely in the context of American
education.
Disciplinary Learning
February 5, 1995
Interdisciplinary learning is an attractive idea. But a discipline is not an
arbitrary set of restrictions that keep us from seeing the whole picture. It is an
essential body of information, built up over the centuries, about how to explore a
particular area of knowledge.
Debating
the Standards
January 29, 1995
The history standards are not an argument against Goals 2000 and its
standards-setting process; they are a vindication.
Testing Teachers
January 8, 1995
If states instituted serious pre-employment tests for new teachers, they would
undoubtedly face some tough challenges. But if we expect standards-based reform to go
anywhere, teachers will need to have a good grasp of the subject matter they are charged
with teaching.
Back to Standards Homepage
Top of Page | Home | Links | Search This Site
About Us | About Albert Shanker | Education
| Labor | Democracy |