• The Politics of Interpretation: Critical Discourse Analysis and Education Policy

    Introduction

    Ever since the rise of the digital age, we have found ourselves living just finger-taps away from a seemingly endless amount of information. We have all become accustomed to the phrase “don’t believe everything you see on the internet” but what about the information we read from institutions and sources we consider neutral or trustworthy? We often extend a certain level of trust to these sources without necessarily questioning how that trust is established or maintained.  Within politically polarized debates, complex policy issues can be communicated through simplified explanations, selective language and competing narratives. Language is not simply a means of communicating information; it is a tool for constructing meaning, shaping how we understand issues, reinforcing existing beliefs, and emphasizing particular perspectives without necessarily presenting information that is factually false. The words we choose, the way we structure sentences, and the information we emphasize or omit can influence how a policy is interpreted, and which consequences receive our attention. Even technical or seemingly neutral language can obscure important distinctions, including a policy’s potential implications for equity. As members of the public, we have a responsibility to hold institutions accountable for how they communicate information and to critically examine the language being used, regardless of its source or whether it aligns with our existing beliefs.

    Recently, I came across a press release from the U.S. Department of Education announcing the rescission of federal civil rights guidelines for vocational education programs. Even before examining the text itself, it is important to consider the institutional context from which it originates. As a federal agency responsible for administering and distributing billions of dollars in funding across K-12 and higher education, the Department carries significant institutional authority. This authority may shape how readers initially perceive the information it communicates, potentially lending the press release a degree of credibility or legitimacy before its language and claims are examined more closely. However, institutional credibility does not necessarily mean that the language used to communicate the policy decision is neutral or free from particular perspectives. The press release provides an opportunity to examine how an institution communicates a complex policy decision, emphasizing certain aspects of the recission while giving less attention to others. Linguistic choices are significant because they shape how the policy change is represented without necessarily establishing whether the Department’s claims are accurate or inaccurate. By applying Norman Fairclough’s Three-Dimensional Model of Critical Discourse Analysis, I examine the choices made like specific vocabulary, grammatical choices and institutional contexts of this press release to understand how that meaning was constructed and communicated. Through this analysis, I argue that critically examining the language of official communications is essential to public accountability because understanding a policy requires considering not only what an institution tells us, but how they choose to tell it.

  • Lessons from Hungary and History: People Power is How We Prevail


    AFT-ASI President Randi Weingarten (L) and AFT Massachusetts President and Shanker Institute Board Member Jessica Tang (R) examine some of the classroom resources of Hungarian History teacher János Bősze (C).


    As a social studies teacher and leader of the AFT’s Resistance Committee, I know we stand to learn a great deal from Hungary – by looking at both its past and present. 

    However, nothing could have prepared me for hearing firsthand what Hungarian union educators, activists and community leaders had to say about their own experiences over the past 16 years and beyond. It galvanized a deeper understanding of both how our democratic backsliding can get much worse, but also how it can be overcome. 

    As we heard local Hungarians recount their experiences as part of their resistance movement, it was impossible to ignore the eerie and all too familiar undercurrent that accompanied each discussion we had with them. Connecting with our union siblings and democracy activists made it clear that the experience of authoritarianism is global, as are the challenges we face in public education. The similarities between their experiences and what we are seeing as Project 2025 is being implemented throughout the nation became abundantly clear.

  • They Did It in Hungary; We Can Do It Here too.


    AFT leaders meet with Budapest Mayor Gergely Karacsony. (L-R Stacy Davis Gates, President of AFT Illinois and the Chicago Teachers Union; Wendy Coleman, President of AFT Pennsylvania; The Honorable Gergely Karascony, Mayor of Budapest; Randi Weingarten, President of AFT and Albert Shanker Institute; Jeff Freitas, President of AFT California; and Jessica Tang, President of AFT Massachusetts.)

    The attacks on our democracy aren’t happening in a silo. This is happening around the world, and it’s all connected.

    I spent last week in Hungary with AFT President Randi Weingarten and three other AFT vice presidents: Illinois Federation of Teachers President Stacy Davis Gates, AFT Massachusetts President Jessica Tang and AFT Pennsylvania President Wendy Coleman. We had the opportunity to attend the Budapest Forum, where Randi spoke on a panel about resilient democracies in a fractured world. There was a sense of hope and a sense of urgency because, after this year’s election defeating authoritarian Prime Minister Victor Orbán, Hungary has a chance to get it right.

    I’m a math teacher, not a civics or history teacher like Randi. For many of us, these concepts are just that: ideas removed from reality. But as a labor leader, I get to see them in play, and the discussions we had this week were about how we can make democracy real for people.

    Democratic backsliding. Authoritarianism. Illiberal democracy. We know these are bad. But what do they mean in practice?

  • What I Learned About Standing Up for Our Democracy From Traveling to Hungary

    AFT leaders meet with Mayor of Budapest
    AFT Pennsylvania President Wendy Coleman and AFT-ASI President Randi Weingarten meet with Budapest Mayor Gergely Karacsony.

    Recently I had the opportunity to accompany AFT President Randi Weingarten and three of my fellow AFT vice presidents — Illinois Federation of Teachers and Chicago Teachers Union President Stacy Davis Gates, AFT Massachusetts President Jessica Tang and CFT President Jeff Freitas — on a solidarity mission to Budapest, Hungary. In case you’re not familiar with Hungary’s political landscape and are wondering why AFT leaders would travel to the Eastern European nation: In April 2026 the country voted to oust authoritarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán after 16 years in power. This victory was years in the making by everyday people, including educators and students, who organized and protested against Orbán’s corruption and his crackdown on free speech, democracy, public education, immigration and human rights.

    If that situation sounds familiar to you, there’s a reason: Donald Trump and his administration have long praised Orbán and have cited his autocratic government as a model to follow. We’ve seen the Trump administration attack our elections, try to undermine public education, infringe on a free press and violate human rights, and much like in Hungary, it is educators, unions, students and organizations across the U.S. that are pushing back against Trump’s attempts to erode our democracy and enshrine himself and his party in power.

  • Encore Careers: Serving the Public Interest After 80

    Our guest author is Stanley Litow, a professor at Columbia University's School of International and Public Affairs and a Shanker Institute Board Member.

    At the end of the Biden Presidency there was a lot of discussion about whether people who pass the 80-year threshold should even be in public service at all, let alone be President. That view has intensified since the current White House occupant turned 80. And recent and upcoming elections have focused on replacing seniors in office, at all levels,  with a next generation of leadership. Given that I recently turned 80 and a few weeks later my older brother passed away at age 83, I have a personal view of what living past age 80 or serving the public interest, means,  and what a post-80 life means.

    I retired after a 50 plus year career, including service as President of the IBM Foundation, time as NYC Deputy Schools Chancellor, founder of a major think tank and head of the Educational Priorities Panel plus City Hall service under Mayor Lindsay heading the NYC Urban Corps.  A long and satisfying set of experiences. During my service as Deputy Chancellor NYC adopted the "children of the rainbow" early grades diversity curriculum.  At IBM I helped organize three National Education Summits for the President of the United States, the nation's Governors, CEO's and school leaders, but my most significant achievement was designing a new combined high school and college model, called PTECH where students get both a high school and no cost college degree concurrently with a clear pathway to successful careers. This includes mentors and paid internships. PTECH started with one school in Brooklyn but spread globally, and now over 100,000 students across 600 schools are enrolled. Students who were not expected to achieve, are achieving at nationally high levels with mentors to aid in their school years. Just recently a new national not for profit the PTECH Alliance has formed to spread the PTECH opportunity to far more young people.

  • A Common Sense Approach to Demystify Universal Reading Screening with Multilingual Students

    Our guest author is Lillian Durán, a professor in the Department of Special Education and Clinical Sciences at the University of Oregon. She develops language and literacy screening measures in English and Spanish and consults nationally regarding best practices in assessment with multilingual learners. 

    Children learn the languages they are exposed to across their daily lives, but children acquire the ability to read in a language through formal instruction. Awareness of this fundamental difference between language and literacy skill development is at the core of making common sense decisions regarding the screening of multilingual students for reading problems. 

    Universal Screening for reading development issues including dyslexia during the early elementary school years is now mandated or recommended in 49 states in the U.S. which naturally necessitates that all children are tested with the assumption that screening will accurately identify those children who will benefit from more targeted instructional support to reduce the likelihood that they will fall further behind in their reading development. The goal is to deliver effective and evidence-based reading intervention early that is likely to prevent reading failure before it becomes entrenched. 

  • Proficiency or Penalty? Grade Retention Policy and Its Implications for English Learners in Utah

    One common goal of public education is to ensure all students reach academic mastery. In fact, most U.S. states have agreed upon a set of aligned standards of mastery through the Common Core. To that end, it may make sense to lawmakers that students repeat third grade and get another ‘at bat’ if they weren’t able to reach reading proficiency. This theory of change— accountability in action— has prompted many states to reinforce their literacy legislation with retention provisions. Eighteen states, including the District of Columbia, require grade retention for nonproficient third graders with varying good cause exemptions. Oklahoma and Utah both added retention requirements in their 2026 literacy legislation. Our study seeks to determine whether the theory of change used by lawmakers aligns with existing research on grade retention.

    In the aftermath of burgeoning grade retention policies, scholars and stakeholders are questioning whether retention will improve outcomes, or if it will become another reform that unintentionally punishes marginalized families. By interviewing stakeholders in one of Utah’s most diverse school districts, Granite, we aimed to answer the following question: what are the long-term implications of retention provisions in Utah's literacy legislation for third graders? Through qualitative interviews and a literature review on the impacts of grade retention, we found that rather than targeting evidence-based interventions, the policy risks displacing responsibility onto families least equipped to absorb it. 

  • Time: The Missing Ingredient in Literacy Reform

    Guest authors Jack Schneider and Ashley Carey are two of the co-authors of On the Clock: The Centrality of Time in Teacher Work, a new research brief published by the Albert Shanker Institute.

    Across the country, states are rushing to adopt “science of reading” legislation. The motivations are sincere, and the research base is substantive. New curricula promise better outcomes; professional development workshops aim to equip teachers with evidence-based practices; data systems can help educators track student progress. From a distance, it seems comprehensive enough to close the nation’s yawning literacy gaps.

    But policymakers have largely overlooked a critical ingredient that will almost certainly determine whether these reforms prove successful. And if you’re a teacher, you probably already know what it is.

    Consider Ms. Smith, a second-grade teacher with a decade of classroom experience. She’s committed to her students and she understands why the new literacy approach matters. She wants to implement it well.

    But she’s drowning.

    The new curriculum requires her to learn new instructional methods. The assessment system requires one-on-one reading screeners for each of her 24 students—a process that eats up two full instructional days. New data management systems demand hours of tracking and reporting. And all of this has been added to everything Ms. Smith is already doing. 

  • Juneteenth, Truth-Telling, and the Power of Union-Supported Educators

    Our guest author is Karla Hernández-Mats, a respected voice for public education who brings a deep understanding of the education system, from inside the classroom to executive leadership who is currently Chair of Educated. We Stand and an AFT Vice President.

    As we commemorate Juneteenth—-a day that marks both delayed freedom and enduring resilience—-we are reminded that history is not just something we inherit, but something we actively teach, shape, and defend.

    In today’s educational landscape, that responsibility carries new weight.

    Across the country, educators are navigating a growing number of policies and political pressures designed to narrow curriculum, discourage honest conversations, and promote a version of teaching that is sanitized, disconnected, and, ultimately, self-centered. These efforts do more than limit content. They attempt to redefine the purpose of public education itself, shifting it away from critical thinking, identity development, and collective understanding.

    But classrooms do not thrive under silence. Students do not grow from half-truths.

    The research, presented in Unionized Teachers of Color’s Interpretations of the Silencing of Diversity Discourse in Florida: An Intersectional Qualitative Study, underscores a critical truth: educators of color consistently emphasize the importance of teaching authentically by drawing on lived experiences, cultural knowledge, and historical accuracy to foster deeper student engagement and identity development. This is not supplemental work. It is essential.

  • The Accountability Gap: D.C. Schools and Students with Disabilities

    When I first moved to D.C., it took me some time to get used to the school system. Multiple city agencies share oversight of public schools, and enrollment is split nearly evenly between traditional public and charter schools— making finding a teaching job strenuous (lots of separate fingerprint appointments!). It wasn’t until I was in the classroom that I grasped how exhausting this fragmented system is for families. Witnessing the difficulty of transitioning from a public to a charter school was one of many consequences of this fragmentation. One of my parents moved to an online charter school because she was told her family would get more targeted support, only to realize that she had to quit her job to monitor her child’s lessons adequately due to her child’s ADHD.

    In December 2024, the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights (OCR) confirmed these challenges by releasing a report from their investigation on DCPS for discrimination of students with disabilities (SWD). In this report, the Commission highlighted two findings of discrimination: DCPS relies on due process complaints to deal with injustice, and they fail to provide transportation services for SWD that require it. 

    These observations contribute to a larger pattern of fragmented governance for marginalized students. The District of Columbia's education governance system is structurally fragmented in ways that obscure accountability and prevent meaningful community participation. Because D.C. functions simultaneously as a city and a state, its education agencies operate across overlapping and competing jurisdictions with no single body held democratically accountable for outcomes. This fragmentation did not flourish on its own; policy actors have prioritized market-based ideologies that treat parents like consumers in a free market. As a result of this neoliberal model, families in need are left with improper access to school resources and civic engagement. Both community and researcher voices agree that D.C.’s governance system requires structural reform to enforce democratic accountability and promote equitable access to high quality public and charter schools to all students.